After 3 games I can say madden is the better game here.
Okay I have both now and I hate to say it, but Madden has really found a great mix in this engine. The Ai challenges you to think about your plays, I used the same play 3 times and it only worked once. While the graphics and presentation go to Espn, the gameplay goes Madden. Madden 04 was a scoring fans dream, 05 is a strategy fans heaven. I love the hits in this game, just brutal. I do not see aas many dumb Ai mistakes as in 2k5. There are a few things that suprised me, maybe Madden heads can help me out here.
1. Why most teams have so much frreakin cap room? I play as the Bears and had over 23 mill in cap room. Is this normal for the series?
2. The contract negotians need to have the style ESPN uses, but still pretty solid.
3. The controls need to be tweaked in this series, the 2k series has the best control set up.
Other than those things, which are really minor, the game plays amazing ball.