Quote:
Originally posted by junkhead
Yeah, you could be right Peepers. It's just that this guy has written a ton of reviews on Gamespot for Xbox. He's one of tose guys who complains if anything on XBox drops below 60 fps. He'll also go on and on about something that is wrong on the Xbox verison of a game, while completely ingoring the same thing on the PS2 version. It drives me crazy that, no mater what the scoring policy, a multi-platform game will actually get a higher score on the PS2!!! Even if the game looks better, supports HDTV, or whatever on the Xbox!!
Right. That's the point. Consider the a typical muli-platformer: it might use every bit of power on the PS2, but if it only looks marginally better on the Xbox, then it's falling short of its potential. Just as it's only fair to rate gameboy games against other gameboy games, its only fair to rate PS2 games against other PS2 games. So while this game might look really great compared to other PS2 games, it's Xbox version will look sup-par compared to many other Xbox games. Therefore, the PS2 version might get a 9.8 in the graphics department while the Xbox version only gets a 7.6, even though the Xbox version looks better. The same goes for all other areas (sound, AI etc.). If a game doesn't make the most of the Xbox's potential, it's not going to look very good compared to the Xbox games that do, thus the lower rating.
Quote:
If anything, Xbox should always score higher for sound just because of Dolby 5.1 support in-game, but it never does. In that respect, Gamespot fals to follow thier own ratings policy.
I don't know too much about the differences in audio support for the Xbox vs the PS2, but this still seems justifiable. IIRC, the Xbox supports more simultaneous channels of audio and its superior processing power allow better amplification/fading as you approach/move away from an audio source. That would seem to justify the higher standards. I've also seen Xbox games lose audio points for failing to include custom soundtrack support, another example of holding the Xbox to a higher standard.