Best 3D Fighter to Grace the Xbox

[Brutus]

Let's end this darn argument once & for all! It's on!
Between the Xbox 3D fighters, which should take the Reign as the Champion Fighter?!

DOA3: Tight Controls, stellar HDTV Graphics & lighting, Tight Physics, Nice Character Selection, Destructible Environments, & Huge Arena's (Remember those Steep Rocky Cliffs) Sound: 5.1 DD
Add that with the believable storyline that portray's everyone's goals (Including Ryu in Ninja Gaiden with Ayane!!!) & you've got my favorite Fighter.

Soul Caliber 2: Wow! Swords! Nice Character Selection. Shoddy Graphics, Nice Physics though, even though they're drastically overdone (Flying into the air...). Regular Old Arena. Non-Destructible Environments & a cliff that you can fall into the Cheesiest sounding water I've ever heard, or just fall forever.
The different weapon's choice is different & convenient. It adds to more depth in a video game but controls either a Vertical or a Horizontal Attack. Dolby Surround & a storyline that is straight out a Dorks & Dragon's Novel. Overall, IMO, good game, not a keeper. It's done & will go down in History just like the fighters who fight the Fireball man, who doesn't have a life, he's just several different people's lives in the midst of fire.

Mortal Kombat - Deadly Alliance: I can't stand this game. If you like Unrealistic flailing pieces of your non-Human & 6 armed guys with one eyball & Fatalityies (You may it's just not mine) Then you'll vote for this one. I don't really know why you guy's would buy this but they've sold a few of em' so if this is your cup of tea, you'll buy it.

The real Decision, IMO, is which of the top two do you like more? Honestly, DOA kicks butt. Always has, always will. Everyone just seems to look past it's greatness.
But, with the English in Soul Caliber 2 & the weapons it seems to hold it's own as a fun Arcade. Then the true arcade, Mortal Kombat.

Vote: Best All Around! Let's see who runs away with it!

Don't forget the controls of the game! How tight are they!?

Sound, & Visual Candy, (Not just, "She kicks high," or, "Check Ivy's blessed Chest!"

How long you've been indulging in it. Soul Caliber & Mortal Kombat have a pretty long "Campaign" For all it's worth. DOA has new downloads & Outfits. It also carry's multiple games that don't suck. DOA: Ryu & Ayane as opposed to Soul Caliber: Spawn.

Go ahead & post all your reasons. Remember, this is the debate to end all debates!

[Shadow20002]

Dead Or Alive 3.

[Brutus]

& Who can forget the first time they threw someone out the DOATEC Window?!

[Young_Fledgling]

soul calibur... weapon fighting is much funner.

[Sigma]

I personally like DOA 3 a tad bit better then Soul Calibur 2, but both are great games and in there own right. MKA is a good game as well, but just not in the same league as SC2 and DOA 3 IMO.

[LTM360]

Dead or Alive 3.

Soul Calibur II is crap, and Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance is even more crap. And I expect the same crap for the next Mortal Kombat... *yawn* just give me Dead or Alive: Ultimate already.

[SoundX]

Soul Calibur 2,

Out the the three it's the most tactical, you need to think about what your doing and not just mash the buttons untill you get a KO. Button Bashers will can not hold their ground on this one, which is why I love it. You actualy need skill for this, and lots of practise.
It has an in depth story mode, which works with lots of different stipulations and rules, a wide range of weapons to buy which actualy effect your perfomance and aren't just for show.
Overall, just a much better game.

[Casper]

Soul Calibur 2,

Out the the three it's the most tactical, you need to think about what your doing and not just mash the buttons untill you get a KO. Button Bashers will can not hold their ground on this one, which is why I love it. You actualy need skill for this, and lots of practise.
It has an in depth story mode, which works with lots of different stipulations and rules, a wide range of weapons to buy which actualy effect your perfomance and aren't just for show.
Overall, just a much better game.

What he said.

SC2 is the only true fighting game - MK is too complex for it's own good, and they overkill the blood. And DOA takes no skills to master, or beat a master.

[Brutus]

Holy Moly! It's neck & neck! I didn't know that that many people liked SCII.
Man, I remember way back on the Dreamcast I made my decision that DOA was the better fighter.
It's a no contest IMO.
I just think that they're both in their own leagues. I can appreciate the weapons but they ought to make it more immense of an adventure. Graphics, Sound, controls. I mean, if they through a few destructable environments in there & made the stages bigger that a small intersection than I might appreciate them more, you know!

[CMX Jedi]

SC 2
i like to play games with inf health, the only way to win is to knock your friend off the ledge takes a while but still fun

[JJaX]

SC2, I can go on and on...

[Brutus]

Jjax, you ain't nothing but a dirty Jersey. Like that fat kid on the football squad that spent most of the day on the ground.
Then afterward he get's his arse spanked red by a bunch of wet towels
Hahah! That's you, dirty jersey. Just for liking an inferior game!

[callum]

Mortal kombat: DA

[SoundX]

Mortal Kombat? Callum, Callum, Callum. You need to get yourself a copy of Soul Calibur 2

[Brutus]

Disregard that. You need a copy of DOA3 with the Booster Disc!

[JJaX]

Jjax, you ain't nothing but a dirty Jersey. Like that fat kid on the football squad that spent most of the day on the ground.
Then afterward he get's his arse spanked red by a bunch of wet towels
Hahah! That's you, dirty jersey. Just for liking an inferior game!

Brutus...

Suck my nuts. Go play DOA with your mouth open you button mashing slob.

[Brutus]

Brutus...

Suck my nuts. Go play DOA with your mouth open you button mashing slob.

Jjax, I'm so not like that, bro.

I know a few Open guy's though that are into that sort of thing. Maybe they could go to your house & sit down for some SC? You guys could sit around eating Captain Crunch while trying to stick the other with your sword... Unless you're Kilik, you could just smack him with your Staff.

But like I said, I'm just not like that. Sorry.

[SoundX]

Disregard that. You need a copy of DOA3 with the Booster Disc!

There's a booster disc?

[Brutus]

There's a booster disc?

Yes.
Allowed for your character's to have an extra choice between 2 - 4 new costumes.

Kept the old ones & made a save file on the HardDrive. From that save was all of the new costumes.

It really brought up the theory that their was a "Nekkid" Mod on the Dead Or Alive Xtreme Beach Volleyball Game. I don't know if their is. But everyone want's it.

Here's a link:
http://www.gamespot.com/xbox/action/...s_2863920.html

Best supported & Best Control along with Best Graphics & Environments = best 3D fighter.

[Darkside]

Sou Calibur 2.

Much more fun than DOA. Much more stuff to DO than DOA. Better than DOA.