What was the most over rated x-box game?

[mattgame]

The most overrated game is GTA I mean all of them. Saints Row got em beat.

[Reclaimer]

Overrated Xbox game?
Brute Force.

Overhyped, huge advertising campaigns at video game stores, tons of freebies to pre-order the game, OXM claiming the game to be a Halo killer in terms of gameplay and graphics.
I felt like the game was fairly mediocre at best.
Sure it was a pretty game, but it was repetitive as all hell and the multiplayer was boring because each of the game's characters were run of the mill and boring.

As far as this Halo 2 versus Halo CE crap..
Halo 2 shines in it's own way, just like how Halo CE shines in it's own.
But, the gaming community ruined Halo 2 with it's level boosting, standy-bying, and verbal abuse.

[mattgame]

And don't forget tea-bagging.

[Slowride]

Halo, Halo 2, Halo 3, Halo 4, etc.....

oh and GTA....what a pile of **** that game is.

[scozzard]

It's got to be Fable,

The game promised a lifetime of fun and provided a little more than 8 hours gametime to complete.

I'd give my right nut to get those hours back.

[Slacker]

Brute force,
halo 2

nuff said

[nesgamingcom]

brute force by a mile man that game sucked

[addict]

Halo 1&2